Helical Piers Cost vs Concrete Footings

Helical Piers Cost vs Concrete Footings

Helical Piers Cost vs Concrete Footings

If you thought that digging holes and placing concrete footers were the only two options, think again: helical piers. But what exactly does this system comprise, and how much does it cost in comparison to regular concrete footers?

During the drilling process, steel poles are pushed into the ground until they come into contact with solid rock or load-bearing soil. In a standard concrete foundation, the ground is dug up about 12 feet, but your footers remain resting in soil. This increases the likelihood of settling and foundation concerns in the future.

Comparison Of Helical Piers Cost vs Concrete Footings

It costs around $186 to construct each pier, and two piers are needed each hole. You’re looking at something in the neighborhood of $373 per hole, and a project normally requires 6 to 12 of them according to the perimeter length of the foundation footprint. It costs between $2,285 to $3,004 to work with hard materials.

Hard materials, such as concrete, might cost different prices depending on the specifics of your project. The important thing to remember is that, not only are you spending a considerable amount of time excavating and pouring concrete, you’re also spending thousands of dollars in labor.

Following the completion of the excavation project, it is necessary to calculate in the cost of yard restoration to be reimbursed.

Overall, the installation piers is at least 27% more efficient than excavating, and many property owners discover that piers are the same price or less expensive than digging for a sturdier, more stable system than they anticipated.

That may seem like a high amount to pay for one pier, and you may be correct in your assessment. However, as a point of contrast, consider concrete piers. In this case, a pit must be excavated and concrete poured to serve as a foundation for the structure. Concreting piers in gardens and other pier applications is most certainly the most often utilized solution for pier construction.

Cost Efficiency Relation Between Helical Piers And Concrete Footings

Pros

  • No more digging holes. With helical piers, there’s no longer a need to dig massive holes or to brace them to prevent collapse. This speeds up the project, but it also means you don’t have to take on the expense of paying highly skilled, trained builders and contractors to manually dig holes.
  • Less yard repair. When you use a traditional footer system, you’re potentially digging up and destroying large swaths of the homeowner’s yard. With the pier system, you don’t have to take on that expense or hassle.
  • Quicker installation. Using the helical piers takes about thirty minutes a hole. For an entire project, that means you can allot about one half day. With digging, contractors had to allow at least two days for the actual excavation, one day for concrete, one days for inspection, and another day just in case something went wrong (foul weather, waylaid concrete delivery, inspection reschedule). That’s upwards of five days in hassle and labor expense with digging and less than one day with helical piers.
  • No curing required: Related with the point above about the “Quick installation”. In the comparison helial piers cost vs concrete footings, a clear advantage for helical piers is that they do not have a curing time.
  • Verifiable load capacity. When digging holes, the contractor had to verify the ground was solid by hand. With helical piers, you use a machine that actually gives you a verifiable, accurate, specific reading.
  • 100 percent pass rate with the inspector. Because the machine tells us exactly how deep to go based on the torque being exerted back on that machine, we know we’re getting it correct every time. When the inspector comes out to assess the piers, we simply give him the printout of our digital readings, and we are given the green light. We have a 100 percent pass rate, and not dealing with multiple inspector visits also helps to speed up the project immensely.
  • Installation can be performed year round: Can be installed well below the frostline, and is not susceptible to frost heave
  • Helicals are a permanent foundation solution, that will last you a lifetime

Cons: Not a DIY activity

Installing helical piers is not a DIY job, unless the installation is required for very small and light structures. The problem is that the homeowner cannot measure with precision the torque required for the installation of each pier.

The truth is that for concrete footings applies the same statement. It is not a DIY activity.

Disadvantages Of Concrete Footings In Relation With Helical Piers

  • excavating down below frost line levels
  • sliding in a form of some kind (sonotube)
  • backfilling the form and then pouring in the concrete

Standard acceptable depths for this process are generally 4′. The further north you go though, as temperatures drop and the frost line gets deeper, more depth is required for the piers. This is to avoid heaving as the soils freeze and unfreeze, making the ground unstable.

  1. The footings are prone to frost heave if they are not placed deep enough
  2. Excessive excavating is needed to get below the frost line prior to placement
  3. Footings can settle due to shrinking and unstable soils, making it so the project needs done again
  4. The projects with Concrete footings are labor intensive, adding costs for labor.
  5. Concrete needs to cure
  6. The weather conditions need to be right for installation: Concrete has been used for hundreds of years and take excavating below frostline, sliding in a sonotube, backfilling the form, then pouring concrete. The frostlines can be deeper than 4’, the reason for needing to follow these steps is the soil freezing and unfreezing making the ground unstable.
  7. Often concrete posts cannot be installed the same day

DIY Approach In A Helical Piers Cost vs Concrete Footings Comparison

Even if we have just explained a few paragraphs above in this helical piers cost vs concrete footings analysis that installing these helical piers is not a DIY task, it can be possible with specific light DIY piers for pergolas and decks

You can find them at most local hardware stores for about $25 to $30 (non-standard brackets are extra). They work the same way as the helical piers we installed earlier, but with one big difference — you can do it yourself!

The biggest potential issue with these smaller options is knowing whether their installation is successful. Since you can’t measure the actual torque required to turn the pier into place, you won’t be able to tell just how much weight these piers will support. For this reason, you may only want to consider these for smaller projects. Also, these smaller helical piers usually have a powder-coated finish instead of the more durable galvanized steel finish. 

Helical Piers as A Preferred Choice

 They’re essentially giant galvanized steel shafts with screw-like flanges. To install screw piles, they are twisted into the ground to a depth that the torque required to turn them indicates proper soil bearing capacity.

Usually, installation extends to just below the frost line. They can sometimes even extend to hundreds of feet down, depending on soil conditions.

These piers can be driven into most types of ground. However, if solid bedrock is encountered, it requires some pre-drilling, which will add to your cost. Stony soils are okay, but sometimes you might hit a large enough rock to have to start the process all over again and reposition the screw.

Recommended Articles

We have some articles that I would like to recommend to the readers.

Foundation Repair And Maintenance

We have described here the type of foundations, what is a foundation inspection and what should be included in a good foundation inspection checklist. We can discover problems in the foundation to make us ask ourselves if it is safe to live in a house with foundation problems, and what entails a foundation repair. Not only the repair activity itself but how it affects our wallets.

I explain if the foundation repair is actually covered by homeowners insurance and the actual foundation repair cost. We disaggregated these foundation repair costs and determined, the cost per pier when footings or piers are the solutions for the settlement of a foundation.

To repair a foundation, the service provider might require an underpinning system using piers: push piers vs helical piers where helical piers are preferable for residential real estate objects, despite their costs. Also when you compare helical piers with concrete footings, we can determine that helical piers are more cost-efficient than concrete footings, in my opinion.

We have water in the crawlspace, which can be an issue for the whole foundation if the problem persists, and an additional difficulty when selling a house with water in the crawl space, as it can provide the prospective buyer with a lot of bargaining power, so what can we do: I explain what to do when the crawlspace is flooded or there are simply puddles of water always standing, thus I describe how to remove quickly the water in the crawlspace and how to prevent the problem for the future. So I discuss if it is normal to have water in the crawlspace after a heavy rain, and the importance to perform a crawlspace waterproofing thereafter, normally by installing a vapor barrier.

I describe how to improve the air quality in the crawlspace and to accomplish this, I am reluctant to use lime powder in this article, where I explain the pros and cons, as I would be using lime powder only to avoid the dangers of raw sewage under the house.

We discuss the sill plate replacement cost and how to avoid the outdoor sump pump freezing because it happened to me once.

There are always new methods for repairing foundations. One of them that we investigate here is the Powerbrace foundation repair method.

Animals can be a problem when they live near the foundation: In the following articles, we describe how to remove them and how to prevent them from digging and burrowing. The articles are about animals digging holes around the foundation or when they are burrowing below concrete, below a concrete slab, or between gaps in concrete footings, for example.

In regards to basements, I describe how to solve the hydrostatic pressure in the basement, which is a lateral pressure that is the main cause for having a basement wall that is bowing, or that can be caving in or buckling. While a slight inward curve for basement wall bowing is acceptable, after that degree, you have to address the issue and face sometimes relatively high basement wall repair costs.

I provide to you some reasons why we will need a certified specialist to deal with a risky sewage backup in the basement because bacteria survive a long time in a contaminated sewage network, and also we discuss how to deal with a basement drain backing up in general and what to do when it happens only when flushing the toilet, something that is not a DYI project at all.

Concrete

I explain here the process of concrete lifting or concrete raising, which can be done through mudjacking or slabjacking. We recommend the latter, which injects polyurethane foam.

Framing

There are some interesting articles here, in this Framing category. I refer to sistering floor joists, as a methodology to reinforce existing floor joists with some emphasis on sistering 2x6 floor joists or sistering with 2x8 instead, and about the building code for sistering joists, for sistering rafters, and the code for notching floor joists.

Many of these problems have a consequence: sinking or sagging floors.

Water Heaters

About water heaters, we have a complete guide about water heater types and their installation requirements, about power vent water heaters, and venting in tankless devices, and I also explain in detail the difference between a mobile home water heater and a standard water heater. I also describe in detail how to remove the heating element without an element wrench using just a socket, and how to fix leaks.

We have a few reviews when a water heater falls into our hands, such as the Titan product portfolio, Navien lineup, the Titan N-160 reviews, the most praised by our readers, and the Rinnai R94LSi.

I study several water heater capacities and tested 20-gallon water heater units and a comparison between point of use and tankless water heaters.

We open a tankless water heater to show how does it look like inside a tankless water heater, and how to protect your water heater against the effects of hard water. I also explain the pros and cons of tankless water heaters because many people consider that tankless units are better than standard heaters and it is not always the case.

After the lifecycle of the water heater is over, I reveal to you different options to proceed with its disposal.

Electricals

Just because they became popular and related to current news, I study how to identify aluminum wiring and once discovered, how to proceed with its remediation or retrofit.

Pest Control

I have a featured article where I compare Orkin vs Terminix pest control services.

Photo of author

BY M. Kogan

Hello, I am Marcio. I am an architect and designer, alma mater is Mackenzie. Retired in theory, but an architect never retires completely. Along with architectural projects, I am a filmmaker and have completed some short documentaries. Filmmaking and design are my passions. In HomeQN I write about home decoration and foundations. The goal is to teach homeowners to DYI as much as possible, and when this is not possible, enable them through knowledge, to evaluate service quotations and choose the best service technicians.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.